• Profile photo of Morphies Dream

      Morphies Dream posted an update

      3 weeks ago

      Hello, fellow writers and fantasy readers!

      I’m developing an original fantasy world for my novel, and I’d love to hear your honest opinions. I’m not looking for compliments just to make me feel good. I genuinely want to understand what readers find exciting, memorable, and worth investing their time in.

      Before I develop the world further, I’d like to know what YOU would prefer.

      🌌 A brief synopsis of my fantasy world

      My story takes place in a world shaped by ancient civilizations, forgotten secrets, mysterious artifacts, rituals, gods, demons, and powers that ordinary people barely understand.

      At the heart of the world lies a continuous spectrum of magic, ranging from Pure Light to Absolute Darkness, with unusual forces such as Soul Magic and Chaos existing within this broader magical reality.

      Magic isn’t simply about throwing powerful attacks. Mages discover their abilities, develop their understanding, explore ancient places, and uncover powers that may have existed long before their civilizations.

      One of the central settings is the Grand Athenaeum of Eldrath, a gothic, cathedral-like academy where students study magic and swordsmanship. Its history conceals mysteries that may be far more dangerous than anything taught in its lecture halls.

      My protagonist, Hyugi, is a talented but emotionally complicated young mage whose life is shaped by family expectations, personal loss, distrust, and questions about faith. His journey gradually leads him toward secrets involving Soul Magic, a mysterious mentor, a Dark Goddess, and a cult with its own hidden agenda.

      One of the distinctive rules in my magic system is that certain stages offer a mage two possible signature spells, but the mage can awaken only one. The other is permanently lost to them. Meanwhile, some magical paths have strict restrictions: for example, the pure-light path, Aureth, cannot be used to directly kill.

      I want the world to combine magical discovery, mystery, character development, ancient lore, dangerous powers, and darker themes without making the magic feel like a collection of generic elemental abilities.

      However, I’m still developing the story, and I’d love your perspective on what deserves the most attention.

      🗳️ Now, I’d love your opinions!

      1. What kind of protagonist would you prefer?

      A) A naturally gifted genius who is always several steps ahead of others.

      B) A weak, underestimated mage who gradually becomes powerful through effort and discovery.

      C) A talented mage with serious weaknesses, emotional struggles, and moments of failure.

      D) A morally ambiguous protagonist whose intelligence matters more than raw power.

      2. What balance of romance and action would you enjoy?

      A) Primarily action, magic, and adventure, with little or no romance.

      B) Action and romance developed equally.

      C) A slow-burn romance that develops naturally alongside the main plot.

      D) Dark relationships, betrayal, obsession, and complicated emotions.

      3. Which overall atmosphere attracts you most?

      A) A hopeful fantasy world filled with wonder and adventure.

      B) A dark, mysterious world full of secrets, ancient horrors, and uncertainty.

      C) A balance of beautiful wonders and disturbing darkness.

      D) A brutal world where power, politics, and survival dominate.

      4. What kind of magic system would you most enjoy reading about?

      A) A highly structured system with clear rules, ranks, limitations, and progression.

      B) Mysterious magic whose true principles are gradually discovered.

      C) A combination of strict rules and terrifying, poorly understood powers.

      D) Magic based on intelligence, investigation, sacrifices, rituals, and unusual abilities rather than simply destructive power.

      5. What do you think of my Light–Dark spectrum magic system?

      A) Interesting, especially if the spectrum has meaningful consequences.

      B) I would prefer completely separate magical paths with their own identities.

      C) I like it, but Soul Magic and Chaos need more distinctive mechanics.

      D) It risks feeling familiar unless its fundamental laws are genuinely original.

      6. Which setting would you most enjoy exploring?

      A) A gothic magical academy filled with rivalries, secret societies, and hidden histories.

      B) Ancient ruins, forgotten civilizations, forbidden places, and lost artifacts.

      C) A dangerous world of gods, demons, cults, and supernatural mysteries.

      D) All of these, connected through one larger mystery.

      7. How should the protagonist’s power progression work?

      A) He becomes powerful relatively quickly and faces increasingly dangerous enemies.

      B) He struggles for a long time, with every achievement earned through effort.

      C) He has unusual talents but must overcome serious limitations and make difficult choices.

      D) His greatest advantage is knowledge, preparation, and understanding the rules of magic.

      8. Which character conflicts interest you most?

      A) Rivalries between talented mages and their struggle for recognition.

      B) Family expectations, jealousy, grief, and personal identity.

      C) Conflicting loyalties, betrayal, secret motives, and morally questionable mentors.

      D) A mixture of personal conflicts and larger political or supernatural conspiracies.

      9. What role should gods and demons play?

      A) Extremely powerful beings who rarely interfere directly.

      B) Active forces that influence religions, kingdoms, and human decisions.

      C) Mysterious entities whose true nature may be completely different from what people believe.

      D) A mixture of all three, with their motives revealed gradually.

      10. What kind of mysteries would keep you reading?

      A) Mysteries about the protagonist’s family and past.

      B) Secrets hidden inside the academy and its teachers.

      C) Ancient magical civilizations, artifacts, and unexplained historical events.

      D) A long-running mystery connecting the magic system, gods, cults, and the protagonist’s personal journey.

      11. How should violence and darker themes be handled?

      A) Mostly moderate violence, with an emphasis on adventure and wonder.

      B) Serious consequences, morally difficult decisions, and occasional brutal conflicts.

      C) Psychological tension, betrayal, tragedy, and disturbing revelations.

      D) A balanced mixture, where darker moments have meaningful consequences rather than existing only for shock value.

      12. Finally, what matters most to you in a fantasy novel?

      A) The magic system and power progression.

      B) The protagonist and supporting characters.

      C) Worldbuilding, lore, and the feeling of exploring an enormous world.

      D) Plot twists, mysteries, and intelligent storytelling.

      E) Emotional depth, relationships, and meaningful themes.

      F) The combination of all these elements.

      ✍️ A few questions beyond the poll

      I’d especially appreciate your thoughts on these:

      Does my world sound interesting enough to explore, or does anything feel too familiar?

      Would you rather read about an exceptionally talented mage, an underdog, or someone who combines talent with serious flaws?

      What would make a magic academy feel genuinely mysterious rather than just another school with powerful students?

      Do exclusive spell awakenings sound exciting, or would you prefer mages to have more freedom in choosing their abilities?

      What is one fantasy trope you absolutely love, and one you are tired of seeing?

      Feel free to answer using the letters, explain your choices, or suggest something completely different.

      Please be honest, even if your opinion challenges my current ideas. I’m trying to build a fantasy world that readers genuinely want to explore, not merely one that sounds impressive in a synopsis.

      Thank you for taking the time to share your thoughts! 🌑📖